Wednesday, July 20, 2005

Roberts Opinion Tool, Completed

    Note, since almost all 4th Circuit cases are heard before three judges, no one can "join" in a dissent or concurring opinion.

WUDWrote Unanimous Decision
WOWrote Opinion
WCWroge Concurring Opinion
WDWrote Dissent
JUDJoined in Unanimous Decision
JOJoined in Opinion
JDJoined in Dissent
CDWrote Concurring in Part, Dissenting in Part
PCPer Curiam
PRDPetition For Review Denied
2004 - 12
JUD 03-3077 United States of America vs. Serita L. Morton (Argued 11/12/04 DHG, DST, JGR)
JO 02-1199 Entergy Services, Inc. vs. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (Argued 9/10/04 DBS, DST, JGR)
WUD 03-3149 & 03-3150 United States of America vs. Jake West (Argued 10/14/04 DHG, KLH, JGR)
JUD 03-1423 National Treasury Employees Union vs. Federal Labor Relations Authority (Argued 10/12/04 DBS, KLH, JGR)
JUD 03-3061 United States of America vs. Jeffrey L. Morgan (Argued 10/8/04 HTE, KLH, JGR)
WO 03-3100 United States of America vs. Luther E. Mellen, III (Argued 10/15/04 DHG, KLH, JGR)
JUD 03-1038 Northern California Power Agency vs. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, et al. (Argued 11/19/04 ARR, JWR, JGR)
JUD 03-7165 Christopher Manion vs. Roy W. Krieger (Argued 12/8/04 HTE, JWR, JGR)
2004 - 11
JUD 03-1295 Delta Radio, Inc. vs. Federal Communications Commission (Argued 9/13/04 DBS, DST, JGR)
JUD 02-5228 Thaddeus Fletcher vs. District of Columbia, et al. (On Appellant's Petition for Rehearing DHG, ARR, JGR)
JUD 03-7095 Michael H. Price, et al. vs. Socialist People's Libyan Arab Jamahiriya (Argued 9/28/04 DHG, HTE, JGR)
JUD 03-7079 United States of America, ex rel. Richard Williams vs. Martin-Baker Aircraft Company, LTD., et al. (Argued 9/13/04 DBS, DST, JGR)
JUD 03-1369 & 03-1422 Resort Nursing Home, et al. vs. National Labor Relations Board (Argued 9/28/04 DHG, HTE, JGR)
JUD 04-7006 Kerry Fox, et al. vs. American Airlines, Inc. (Argued 10/12/04 DBS, KLH, JGR)
JUD 04-7010 Mick's at Pennsylvania Avenue, Inc., et al. vs. BOD, Inc., et al. (Argued 10/15/04 DHG, KLH, JGR)
2004 - 10
PC 03-5169 National Wrestling Coaches Association, et al. vs. Department of Education (On Appellants' Petition for Rehearing and Petition for Rehearing En Banc)
WUD 03-3026 United States of America vs. Anthony L. Holmes (Argued 9/10/04 DBS, DST, JGR)
WUD 03-3139 United States of America vs. Darin M. Tucker (Argued 9/28/04 DHG, HTE, JGR)
WUD 03-7149 Tracey V. Hedgepeth, as best friend to Ansche Hedgepeth vs. Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority, et al. (Argued 9/17/04 KLH, JGR, SFW)
JUD 01-7203 Cynthia Jacobs Carter vs. George Washington University (Argued 9/10/04 DBS, DST, JGR)
2004 - 09
2004 - 08
JUD 02-3028 United States of America vs. Juan Petis McLendon (Argued 2/6/04 HTE, MBG, JGR)
JUD 02-3102 United States of America vs. Alfred Eli, a/k/a Begod (Argued 2/9/04 HTE, MBG, JGR)
WO 03-7128 United States of America, ex rel. Edward L. Totten vs. Bombardier Corporation, et al. (Argued 4/20/04 JWR, MBG, JGR)
2004 - 07
JUD 03-3037 United States of America vs. Lydell Ellerbe (Argued 2/12/04 HTE, KLH, JGR)
JUD 03-3059 United States of America vs. Dorothy Quigley (Argued 5/10/04 DHG, DBS, JGR)
WUD 01-1480 National Council of Resistance of Iran vs. Department of State, et al. (Argued 4/2/04 KLH, MBG, JGR)
JO 03-7044 Adam Barbour vs. Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority (Argued 2/10/04 DBS, MBG, JGR)
WUD 03-1179 Williams Gas Processing - Gulf Coast Company, L. P., et al. vs. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (Argued 5/10/04 DHG, DBS, JGR)
JUD 01-5432 Cedric Stokes a/k/a Abdus Salaam Muhammed vs. United States Parole Commission (Argued 12/8/03 DHG, ARR, JGR)
WUD 02-1121 Midwest ISO Transmission Owners, et al. vs. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (Argued 4/23/04 DHG, DBS, JGR)
JUD 03-1396 Verizon Telephone Companies, et al. vs. Federal Communications Commission, et al. (Argued 4/22/04 DHG, MBG, JGR)
JUD 03-7121 Rochelle Jaffe, Individually and as Personal Representative of the Estate ofEve Jaffe vs. Pallotta Teamworks, A California Corporation, et al., et al. (Argued 4/20/04 JWR, MBG, JGR)
PC 99-1020 BP West Coast Products LLC vs. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, et al. (Argued 11/12/03 DBS, JWR, JGR)
WUD 03-3069 United States of America vs. Monte F. Brown, Jr. (Argued 3/11/04 DHG, ARR, JGR)
WUD 03-3087 United States of America vs. Arnett C. Smith (Argued 4/20/04 JWR, MBG, JGR)
JUD 03-1213 Communications and Control, Inc. vs. Federal Communications Commission (Argued 4/2/04 KLH, ARR, JGR)
WUD 03-5329 In re: Gordon R. England Secretary of the Navy et al., vs. Consolidated wit (Argued 4/22/04 DHG, MBG, JGR)
JUD 03-7117 Blake Kilburn, Individually on his own behalf, and as Executor of the Estate of Peter C. Kilburn, deceased vs. Socialist People's Libyan Arab Jamahiriya, et al. (Argued 5/14/04 DHG, MBG, JGR)
2004 - 06
JUD 03-1322 American Postal Workers Union, AFL-CIO, Atlanta Metro Area Local vs. National Labor Relations Board (Argued 5/11/04 DHG, DBS, JGR)
JUD 03-3058 United States of America vs. Maurice W. Hayes, a/k/a Mo (Argued 3/12/04 DHG, ARR, JGR)
CD 03-5232 Clifford Acree, Colonel, et al. vs. Republic of Iraq, et al. (Argued 4/7/04 HTE, DST, JGR)
JUD 03-1161 & 03-1192 Stanford Hospital and Clinics vs. National Labor Relations Board (Argued 3/12/04 DHG, ARR, JGR)
JUD 03-7110 The Herero People's Reparations Corporation, a District of Columbia Corporation, et al. vs. Deutsche Bank, A.G., et al. (Argued 4/2/04 KLH, ARR, JGR)
JUD 02-5228 Thaddeus A. Fletcher vs. District of Columbia, et al. (Argued 12/8/03 DHG, ARR, JGR)
WUD 03-1020 Independent Equipment Dealers Association vs. Environmental Protection Agency (Argued 2/10/04 JWR, MBG, JGR)
WUD 03-7092 Bow G. Jung vs. Mundy, Holt & Mance, P.C., et al. (Argued 5/11/04 DHG, DBS, JGR)
JUD 03-7135 Raytheon Company vs. Ashborn Agencies, Ltd. (Argued 5/10/04 DHG, DBS, JGR)
2004 - 05
JUD 03-7075 National Railroad Passenger Corporation vs. Lexington Insurance Company, et al. (Argued 1/9/04 DBS, DST, JGR)
JUD 03-1162 Consumers Energy Company vs. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (Argued 3/8/04 DHG, ARR, JGR)
JUD 03-5256 American Federation of Government Employees, AFL-CIO vs. James M. Loy, In his official capacity as Under Secretary of Transportation (Argued 4/22/04 DHG, ARR, JGR)
2004 - 04
JUD 02-1334 Dunkin' Donuts Mid-Atlantic Distribution Center, Inc. vs. National Labor Relations Board (Argued 12/8/03 DHG, ARR, JGR)
JUD 03-1129 & 03-1146 Evergreen America Corporation vs. National Labor Relations Board (Argued 2/12/04 HTE, MBG, JGR)
JUD 03-1127 National Association of Government Employees, Local R5-136 vs. Federal Labor Relations Authority, Washington, D.C. (Argued 2/6/04 HTE, MBG, JGR)
WUD 03-5163 International Action Center, et al. vs. United States of America, et al. (Argued 2/6/04 HTE, MBG, JGR)
WUD 03-1185 Charles R. Duchek vs. National Transportation Safety Board, et al. (Argued 3/9/04 DHG, ARR, JGR)
2004 - 03
JUD 03-1141 Association of Civilian Technicians, Wichita Air Capitol Chapter vs. Federal Labor Relations Authority (Argued 1/9/04 DBS, DST, JGR)
JUD 02-3073 United States of America v. Lawrence E. Thomas (Argued 12/9/03 DHG, MBG, JGR)
JUD 02-1307 S.A. Storer and Sons Co. v. Secretary of Labor (Argued 10/14/03 KLH, DST, JGR)
WUD 03-3104 United States of America v. David C. Stanfield (Argued 2/9/04 HTE, MBG, JGR)
WC 03-1008 PDK Laboratories Inc. v. Drug Enforcement Administration (Argued 11/7/03 ARR, JGR, SFW)
2004 - 02
PC 03-1215 Gail Godwin vs. Secretary of Housing and Urban Develpment (Submitted JWR, DST, JGR)
WUD 03-1031 & 03-1099 LeMoyne Owen College v. National Labor Relations Board (Argued 12/9/03 DHG, MBG, JGR)
WUD 02-1060 In re: James M. Tennant (Argued 1/9/04 DBS, DST, JGR)
JUD 03-3006 United States of America v. Adrian D. Williams (Argued 1/13/04 HTE, JGR, SFW)
WUD 03-5025 Gilbert M. Graham v. John D. Ashcroft, in his official capacity as U.S. Attorney General, et al. (Argued 1/13/04 HTE, JGR, SFW)
2004 - 01
PC 02-5387 Natural Resources Defense Council, et al. v. Department of Energy, et al. (Argued 11/6/03 ARR, JGR, SFW)
JUD 02-7120 Morris J. Warren v. District of Columbia (Argued 11/13/03 ARR, JGR, SFW)
JUD 03-5020 Julian M. Whitaker, et al. vs. Tommy G. Thompson, Secretary, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, et al. (Argued 11/10/03 ARR, JGR, SFW)
WUD 02-1253 Sierra Club vs. Environmental Protection Agency, et al. (Argued 10/10/03 KLH, DST, JGR)
JUD 02-5304 Robert Harris, et al. vs. Federal Aviation Administration, et al. (Argued 10/10/03 KLH, DST, JGR)
JUD 02-7086 English-Speaking Union vs. James Johnson, et al. (Argued 10/14/03 KLH, DST, JGR)
2003 - 12
PRD 02-1300 International Union of Operating Engineers, Local 470, AFL-CIO v. National Labor Relations Board (Argued 10/17/03 KLH, DST, JGR)
JUD 02-5278 Tax Analysts v. Internal Revenue Service (Argued 10/10/03 KLH, DST, JGR)
JUD 02-3113 United States of America vs. Kinley W. Howard (Argued 11/10/03 ARR, JGR, SFW)
JUD 02-5294 Carey Dunai Lohrenz v. Elaine Donnelly, Center for Military Readiness, et al. (Argued 9/19/03 JWR, JGR, LHS)
PRD 00-1369 & 00-1370 BDPCS, Inc. vs. Federal Communications Commission (Argued 11/6/03 ARR, JGR, SFW)
WUD 03-7016 I.T. Consultants, Inc. vs. Islamic Republic of Pakistan, et al. (Argued 11/7/03 ARR, JGR, SFW)
WUD 02-5391 Sonya G. Stewart vs. Donald L. Evans, Secretary of Commerce, et al. (Argued 11/7/03 ARR, JGR, SFW)
JUD 03-3003 United States of America vs. Michael A. Riley (Argued 11/13/03 ARR, JGR, SFW)
JUD 03-7015 & 03-7053 Recording Industry Association of America, Inc. vs. Verizon Internet Services, Inc. (Argued 9/16/03 DHG, JGR, SFW)
PRD 02-1311 American Federation of Government Employees, AFL-CIO, National Veterans Affairs Council 53 v. Federal Labor Relations Authority (Argued 10/16/03 KLH, DST, JGR)
2003 - 11
JUD 02-3089 United States of America v. Lawrence Michael Seiler (Argued 10/16/03 KLH, DST, JGR)
JUD 02-5277 City of Roseville, A California Charter City, et al. v. Gale A. Norton, in her official capacity as United States Secretary of Interior, et al. (Argued 9/18/03 JWR, JGR, LHS)
WUD 02-1208 & 02-1269 Sioux Valley Rural Television, Inc., et al. v. Federal Communications Commission, et al. (Argued 10/17/03 KLH, DST, JGR)
WUD 02-5311 Felix S. Bloch v. Colin L. Powell, Secretary of State (Argued 10/14/03 KLH, DST, JGR)
WUD 02-7118 & 02-7119 DSMC Incorporated v. Convera Corporation (Argued 10/16/03 KLH, DST, JGR)
2003 - 10
JUD 02-1166 Marseilles Land and Water Company v. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (Argued 9/18/03 JWR, JGR, LHS)
JUD 02-5056 The Williams Companies, et al. v. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (Argued 9/16/03 DHG, JGR, SFW)
WUD 02-1283 Tilak S. Ramaprakash v. Federal Aviation Administration, et al. (Argued 9/18/03 JWR, JGR, LHS)
WUD 02-3085 United States of America vs. Steven M. Bolla (Argued 9/19/03 JWR, JGR, LHS)
PC 01-5387 Brett C. Kimberlin, et al. v. United States Department of Justice, et al. (On Appellants' Petition for Rehearing En Banc)
WUD 02-1312 Consumer Electronics Association v. Federal Communications Commission, et al. (Argued 9/16/03 DHG, JGR, SFW)

No comments: